Last night, after I finished writing, I wasn’t ready to
sleep yet, and so I slipped out of the little room Eleen and I share and went
into the big space where the people who were here before us used to grow their
vegetables. The glass block skylights up
above were pure black, no trace of starlight in them at all, though I was
pretty sure it was a clear desert night and plenty of stars were looking down
on this side of Mam Gaia’s round belly. I sat on the edge of one of the
concrete tubs full of dirt where the vegetables used to be, and looked back up
at them.
I was pretty sure that something was going to happen the
next day, something big. Tashel Ban and Eleen were busy at the computer until
late, and she came to bed with a look on her face that wasn’t the one I
expected. Ruinmen talk about trying to get through a concrete wall by pounding
your head against it, and I’m sure the scholars in Melumi have a more elegant
way of saying the same thing; I know the look Eleen gets when that’s what she’s
been doing, but that wasn’t the way she looked.
She looked frightened. Not frightened as though something’s
come lunging out of the darkness at you, the way Thu came at me on that night
in Memfis; frightened as though everything you thought you could rely on just dropped
from beneath your feet, the way—I was about to write “the way the floor dropped
from beneath my feet in the Shanuga ruins,” but I knew better, any ruinman’s
prentice past his first season knows better, than to think you can ever rely on
an old concrete floor. No, what I ought
to write there is the thing I’m still trying to work up the courage to write,
and that’s what happened when we first reached Star’s Reach and Jennel Cobey
died.
One way or another, I’m going to have to write about that
sometime soon, and sometime not too long after that I’m going to have to deal
with the consequences. When a jennel
gets killed, there are going to be consequences, and I don’t have any reason to
think it’s going to matter much to the people who matter that he was the one
who put the two of us in a situation where one of us was going to get reborn in
a hurry, and all I did was decide that it was going to be him.
But I sat there and stared up at the night, and thought
about the frightened look on Eleen’s face, and all the things we’d learned
about the Cetans, and the night stared down at me and didn’t say a thing.
Finally I got tired enough to sleep, and went to bed.
The next morning I was up before it was light. It was my turn and Anna’s to make breakfast,
and so I washed and dressed and headed for the kitchen. She was already there,
which was unusual. We didn’t see her much before breakfast unless it was her
turn to help with the cooking, and even then she’d get to the kitchen when
things were well along and do most of the serving to make up for it. This time
she was waiting. She didn’t say much most mornings, and this morning she smiled
her knife-curved smile, and watched me out of the corners of her eyes, and
didn’t say a word.
I don’t think any of us said a dozen words during breakfast.
Everyone knew that something was about to happen; people don’t live together as
long as we have, here at Star’s Reach, without getting to sense when a
discovery’s been made or a problem’s come up.
The longer breakfast went on, the thicker the silence got, until finally
Tashel Ban drained his cup of chicory brew and said, “When the rest of you are
finished, there’s something Eleen and I have found that we all need to talk
about.”
The rest of us were finished. Berry and Thu took a couple of
minutes to clear the table, but nobody even thought about washing the
dishes. Tashel Ban waited until they
were back at their places, then leaned forward onto his elbows and said, “We’ve
found the last thing that was put on the computers before the people here
died.”
He stopped there, and after a moment I said, “And?”
“I have no idea what to make of it. It’s not a document. It’s a program, a huge one, and we can’t
figure out what it is or what it’s supposed to do. It’s—” He gave us all his owlish look. “I’m not at all sure how much of an
explanation you would prefer.”
“Details,” said Thu, “are more useful than
generalities. Please go on.”
Tashel Ban sat back in his chair. “I don’t claim to know everything about the
way computer programs were put together back in the old world, but I know a
fair amount. The Nuwingan government has
a few computers that are still in working order—I’m pretty sure the Merigan
government has some, too—and I’ve worked on ours, to the extent of writing code
for simple programs. Look at a program written for the kind of computer they
put here at Star’s Reach, and you know what to expect—what the files look like
when you view them, and so on.
“The program we’ve found is gibberish. Or it looks like gibberish.
It’s got things woven into it that are ordinary pieces of programming code, but
they seem to be lifted out of other programs in the computer, and do things
with those other programs or the operating system that runs the computer. The
rest of it is nonsense, letters and numbers and other things all jumbled
together without any structure I recognize at all. But—” Here he leaned forward
again. “I don’t think it’s actually nonsense. There are patterns in it. I just
can’t figure out the first thing about them.
“So we tried to figure out where it came from and when it
was used—you can find that out from inside the computer if you know how—and
that’s when things got truly puzzling. The program ran just once, a few hours
before the people here tried to delete all their files and then shut everything
down. It was downloaded onto the computer a day before, by another program, a
huge one. This other program was
downloaded onto the system four days before that, spent all four of those days
doing something I can’t figure out, and then deleted itself.
“Then we tried to find out where the big program came from,
and that’s what kept us busy most of yesterday. It looked as though it just
popped up out of nowhere—until we thought of checking the logs for the main radio
receivers. That’s where it came from. There was a radio message, a long one,
that repeated itself over and over again—” He moved his hands in a circle. “And
somehow that set up a repeating pattern all through the communications and
computer system here, and the big program somehow unpacked itself from
that. I don’t know how to do that. I
don’t think anyone anywhere knows how to do that.”
“Clearly someone did,” Thu pointed out. “I wonder if it came from Sisnaddi.”
“Not those receivers,” Tashel Ban told him.
It took just a moment for that to sink in. When it did, Thu’s eyes narrowed. “You are saying that the program came
from—” A motion of his chin pointed
upwards. “Out there.”
“As best we can tell, yes.”
I thought I understood then. “So it’s something from the
Cetans?”
“That’s the question we asked,” Tashel Ban said. “But the
program doesn’t look anything like what the Cetans send, and it doesn’t
correspond at all to what the people here before us were able to learn about
Cetan computing.”
I was still trying to get my head around that when Berry
spoke. “That message,” he said. “The one
that brought the program. When did it
arrive?”
“That was the next question we asked,” Tashel Ban told him.
“I gather you’ve guessed the answer.”
Then, because Thu and I were both looking puzzled: “The main antennas point whichever way this
part of Mam Gaia is facing. Right now, they’re facing Tau Ceti in the morning
hours. More than a few hours to either side, and—” He shrugged. “They’re pointing to another part of the
sky.”
That’s when I realized what he was saying. “So it’s—someone
else.”
“Apparently so,” said Tashel Ban. “And I have no idea what
to make of that.”
We all stared at him, and then someone laughed. It was a dry, harsh laugh like paper tearing,
and it took me a good long moment before I realized that it was coming from
Anna.
“Forgive me,” she said, still laughing. “Of course you don’t
know what to make of that. You haven’t been looking in the right place.” She looked straight at me, then. “You
understand. Or you should. You’re the only one who read the books they left for
us—the only one but me.”
I knew right away what she meant, but before I could think
of any way to answer her, Tashel Ban said to her, “Perhaps you can explain it
to the rest of us, then.”
“If you wish.” She looked at him, and then at the rest of
us. “The Cetans aren’t the reason all of this is here. They were the one species who answered the
radio messages we sent, because they’re right about the same level of
technology we are, and they haven’t been contacted yet by the Others.” The way
she said that last word, you could tell she would have written it with the
capital letter. “The Others are the reason Star’s Reach was built.”
“Another species.”
This from Thu.
She gave him something I’d have called a pitying look from
anybody else. “Thousands of other
species,” she said. “Millions of years
more technologically advanced than we are. They have ships that can travel from
star to star in less time than it took us to walk here from Cansiddi. They have
answers to all the questions human beings tried and failed to find back in the
old world. They were already visiting
this planet before the old world went away.
One of their ships crashed here, at a place called Roswell, off in the
desert, and that’s when the government back then started building Star’s Reach,
to make contact with them, to talk to them and get the technologies that would
keep the old world from ending the way it did.
“But they wouldn’t answer.
We weren’t ready for first contact, not then, not for a long time
afterwards. They knew that if they landed, if they even communicated with us
openly, people wouldn’t be able to bear knowing that we’re nothing more than a
backward species on a backward planet that need all the help the Others can
give us.” She gestured outwards, the movement sharp as broken metal. “Think of
all the people in Meriga who spend their days praying to Mam Gaia. What would they do if they suddenly found out
that their Mam Gaia is nothing more than a grain of dust spinning around an
ordinary star in an out of the way corner of the galaxy?
“So the Others didn’t contact us. They didn’t think we were ready. They didn’t contact the Cetans, either, and
so we and the Cetans made contact with each other, and spent a couple of
hundred years talking back and forth by radio.
And maybe it was that—” She
stopped, and shook her head. “Maybe it
was that, that we were able to communicate with an alien species and bear it,
that convinced the Others that we were ready to be contacted. And when they contacted us, we still weren’t
ready.”
“You think that’s why the people here killed themselves,”
said Eleen.
“I don’t know,” Anna admitted. “I’ve told you already everything I remember;
it was a long time ago, and I was very small.
Still, once I got here and started reading the books they left for us,
it all made sense. And—” She gestured again, palms up. “There were plenty of books here when I was a
child. I remember shelves and shelves of
them everywhere. They must have burned
most of them, but they left the shelf of books about the Others for us to
find. Why?”
“Tell us,” said Eleen.
“To give us the chance to figure out ahead of time that the
Others are out there. I don’t think they
expected anyone to be able to read the computer files, the way you have, but
they probably guessed that when Star’s Reach was found, we’d start talking to
the Cetans again, and sooner or later the Others would try to contact us a
second time. That’s what the program’s for, I’m sure of it—a way to contact
them, or a message from them. They’re
still waiting out there with their advanced technology—waiting for us to be
ready to welcome them, waiting until they can make this world even better than
it was before the old world ended. Waiting to come down and take humanity to
the stars.”
There was a light in her eyes like nothing I ever saw there
before. All at once I remembered the
books we’d both read, the alien-books and the stories about futures out there
in space that never happened, and I knew what was in her mind. I’d read the books and scratched my head and
wondered, but she’d read them and believed all of it, and I thought I could
guess why. “Anna,” I asked her, “did
your parents tell you any of this?”
She turned to face me then.
“A little,” she said. “My mother
told me about the Others just before she died. I didn’t know what to make of
it. Now I do.”
No one else said anything. I glanced around the table. Tashel Ban had his owl-look on; Berry was
pale and distant; Thu still as an old stone. It was Eleen’s face that caught my
eye, though; she was watching Anna with an odd, sad look. It took me a moment
to realize what it meant: Eleen knew
something about all this, something she wasn’t saying. What?
I didn’t know, and there was something that had to be
settled right away. “Tashel Ban,” I
said. “Can you make the program run?”
He nodded. “All I
have to do is type in the command.”
“Thu?”
He was the one who mattered most, just at that moment. If he decided it was time, we’d clear a space
for a circle, he and Tashel Ban would go at each other with knives, and if it
was Tashel Ban’s time to bleed out his life there on the floor, I’d have Berry
or Eleen delete the program and that would be the end of it, until whoever sent
it decided to try again. That was the
agreement we had, and if that was the way things had to go, I knew it would be
better to get it over with at once.
Thu thought about it for a moment, then shook his head. “The program has been run once before, and it
did not bring spaceships down from the skies. I will not invoke our agreement
on the mere possibility that this thing would violate it. If it proves to be a
message or gives access to a technology, then it may be necessary to settle the
matter in the circle. Not until then.”
“I think,” I said then, “we need to run the program, and
find out what it is.”
“Even though the last people who ran it killed themselves?”
Berry asked.
“We have to know,” I said, and after a moment, he nodded.
So we all got up and
went over to the computer. Tashel Ban
typed at the keyboard for a bit, and then glanced back at me. I nodded, and he hit the enter button.
37 comments:
Beautiful! This will separate your readers in to two camps: those who can share old Anna's hope and those who can never do so.
I am in the second camp. I suspect the Others will not prove to be at all benevolent toward us, no more than Monsanto is benevolent toward the weeds its herbicide kills. And so I fire up my crystal ball . . .
To the Others, our planet, with all its lifeforms, and even its sun, may be just another resource to be strip-mined.
If so, then that mysterious program may be an infection that clears a solar system of sentience beyond a certain level, to make the strip-mining process go more smoothly -- a planetary "biocide," if you will.
Or (I think it more likely) the program may be an infection that turns these same sentient beings into zombie-like agents of the strip-mining process. I greatly mistrust the way in which the Others' initial transmission tried to cover its tracks.
In either case, the suicide of the people at Star's Reach may have been their desperate attempt to contain the infection and save the planet.
Or I may be wholly off-target here, my crystal ball a mere deceiver. We shall see, all in the author's own good time.
(Feel free not to post this if it spoils your story too much. I won't be at all offended.)
This just got a bit more Zelazny than I expected it to! But also a little Bashar!! My curiousity is now officially piqued.
Wow, am I cliff-hung now!
Throughout Annas speech I was shaking my head, thinking: 'It can't possibly be this lame.'
From Eleens reaction I can tell that it isn't, but... what is it? It shouldn't be any Alien Space Bats, and if it isn't Cetan it should have a more mundane source... (literally mundane, that is). No idea what it might be!
Am I the only one thinking that somewhere in all that jumbled code one might find the phrase "the owls are not what they seem" and then, a few pages later, "Cooper. Cooper. Cooper"?
Robert, stay tuned...
Xhmko, I've read plenty of Zelazny, and thank you for the compliment. On the other hand -- Bashar? Please explain.
Thijs, okay, that has me even more baffled than xhmko's reference to Bashar.
Was there possibly still an old world satellite cruising around trying to beam info back down to Earth when this program was downloaded? That sounds plausible, but I'm curious to see where the story goes. The dark hints about Trey's encounter with Cobey and Berry's role as a possible heir to the throne are still lurking, and I'm enjoying the suspense.
I wonder, though, what Anna's reaction will be when her beliefs are challenged by what the program will most likely NOT do...
NOW. WAIT. A. MINUTE. You haven't established a basis for Thu and TB to go into the ring. Trey is assuming Tashel Ban will want to run the program; I don't think that's by any means a given. The ring is the option of last resort, when the parties have tried to come to a compromise and failed.
As to space bats...there must have been compelling evidence of the existence of the Others at some point; Star's Reach was funded well into the collapse of the old world, when there were certainly many more practical needs clamoring for those resources. Or is this a case of doubling down after each loss? "Tune in again next month!"
This may be less complimentary, but Bashar is this "alien" channeled by a, well, channeler. Bashar is one of the most bizarre characters I have come across in the new agey movement. Don't know what to make of it all but some of the advice he gives people and his overview of humanity is biting, and often accurate. It ties in with what happened in your story in that he claims that there exists an universal collective type deal of "Others" that are waiting for a point in the future where humanity is ready for contact. There is literally hours and hours, more like days and days, worth of Bashar seminars on youtube. I spent a whole day listening and watching them one day while working on something else. You have to see it to understand how odd this is.
On top of that, according to his channeler, Bashar lives in a triangular spaceshipwith a light on each point, that hovers above Earth. Well the day I listened to him, we went outside for a moment and saw a very unusual stellar occurance. Mars, Saturn and Spica were right there in the sky, in the shape of a triangle, and by the end of the night, at the very end of all the Bashar videos we watched, it was vanishing beyond the western horizon.
Now, I'm a skeptic with and open mind, but that whole day was just something else.
Phew. I got a bit worried there for a second with all the talk of a brighter future, remembering your old spell - "there is no brighter future".
As for the message, there's something of the Andromeda Strain or Stephen Baxter's Zeelee Sequence in it - intelligent life can exist in all sorts of forms, and that may include electromagnetic lifeforms, living in the radio spectrum.
That's the only way I can explain the star-to-star travel part of it, without needing impossibly large sums of energy.
But yeah, the links to Roswell are just sad memories of an old tradition of alien stories.
Let's see. Crazy guesses.
How about: First program is some bootstrapped genetic algorithm system that runs until it wakes up, becomes self-aware, and figures out what's going on at its current location. Then it replaces itself with a child program that runs once and everyone hits the big red panic button, including killing themselves.
The child program phones home?
The child program delivers the aliens in digital form?
Panspermia via interstellar modem?
Maybe a The Thing scenario with the station occupants sacrificing themselves to contain the contagion?
Ah, maybe the robot's hand? Maybe there's something powered off in the basement!
As far as Anna goes, maybe she's just got a case of Cargo cultism going.
I'm content to wait for the next installment and see for myself. I don't have to know right away.
But one thing to consider: You might want to print up a few copies of Star's Reach on acid-free paper. Maybe make sure that they get left on a book shelf in some remote scientific outpost. Maybe in some farmer's attic. Could be a good thing for future generations to find!
regards,
Peter
Sorry about the obscure reference!
It is to the 1990 tv series Twin Peaks. I know you haven't touched a TVset in decades but, well, 1990 is more than twenty years ago, so I thought you might've seen it.
It was so incredibly good that I can hardly imagine a person of taste not having enjoyed it. Especially the first season, which was directed by David Lynch.
It takes place in the North-West, where you hail from if I remember correctly.
Heh heh heh. Other than suggesting that the shortage of alien space bats Meriga has suffered for the last four centuries or so may not be in any hurry to ease up, I'm not going to say a thing. The next installment will reveal -- well, not all, but enough to answer a fair number of questions.
Xhmko, that makes sense. I modeled Anna's claims on the last thirty years or so of UFO literature, which closely parallels what she's been reading at Star's Reach, so the resemblance is not accidental.
Thijs, I stopped watching TV in 1979, so missed Twin Peaks. The comment about the owls seems weirdly reminiscent of Edward Gorey; I can imagine one of his cartoons with an Edwardian gentleman in a park, looking up into a tree with a baffled expression, and the caption, "Bertram discovers that the owls are not what they seem."
Maddening!
:)
If I was a betting man, I'd put my money on the Neeonjins; they seem to have been playing the role of mysterious "others" here and there, and if any place had working computers and the will and skill to design complex viruses, it would be the Seattle-area (or whatever the name has evolved into)...
Love it!
ps- eagerly anticipating the arrival of After Oil via post!
Wow!! I keep reminding myself that JMG discourages "apocalyptic" thinking...now I have to bend the idea of "the Others" into a plausible non-catastrophic storyline that does not use "deux et machina" as a plotline driver...
I like how you included the Dune series as part of the "instruction manual" left behind by the Star's Reach staff, much of Hebert's work is primary to my world-view...
as an aside, have you read any Orson Scott Card? also one of my favorites...if you are familiar with his works, would you consider them to be of the typical "apocalyptic" nature, or of potentially greater literary significance?
BTW, masterful writing, and I am one of those that got out google maps immediately after I recognized that you were using dialect names for real, historical places...
I've been a lurker for a couple of years now and I finally have caught up enough to participate in the commentary...
(Deborah Bender)
My bet is that the message from the Others is a threat. If you continue trying to have an industrial civilization, if you continue attempting to communicate with the Tau Cetians, we will stop you. If you stop doing these things, we will leave you alone, and you want us to leave you alone, because THIS is what we are like.
The rest of the program shows what they are like, in horrifying detail.
A threat of this kind, backed up with menaces, would be enough to motivate any colony of scientists to mass suicide. They would first destroy their library to slow down any future technological recovery, but leave the message itself for posterity to consider if such a recovery should occur.
Well, as this is turning into a guessing game...
my wildest guess is that the Mysterious Program turns out to be a proof that the Cetans were a hoax.
That would probably explain why the original inhabitants of Star's Reach committed suicide, I guess - hundreds of years of dedication to the most important contact humanity aver made, and then suddenly.. Sorry! No Deal!
That would be the cruellest thing I can think of, vis-a-vis teh Star's Reach crew.
Michael, thank you. ;-)
Nick, let me know what you think -- the stories that went into After Oil were my favorites of a fairly large collection.
Dr. MB, thank you. I never really liked what of Card's stuff I read, and don't recall it well enough to place it on the apocalypse scale.
Deborah, stay tuned...
Thijs, that's a very clever suggestion, and one of the few made here that don't drag in an alien space bat or two.
Er.....
After having been reading hundreds of UFOlogical "literature", this is my suggestion:
If aliens are so wise and moral like ufo cultist say, these little green men should not give any tecbbological salvation to barbarian and bewildered planets.
I have been following this story from the start and didn't quite expect potential flying saucers and ray-gun or new-age kind of thing.
It has been a fascinating and, even with the "Cetan's" aspect, sort of logical trip so far thus patience seems necessary to see where you take it from here.
Well, there goes my theory that Anna's a Sword. Who, then? Someone even less likely than Anna, maybe Eleen?
Hmmm... Macroscope meets The Ring...
Maybe Anna's mother had come across some old "Lost" DVDs.
I'm keeping in mind that fiction authors are always free to write about things they don't believe could actually exist.
Myabe it's my age, but am I really the only one of this little band that didn't think "Childhood's End!" at the first mention of the Others? It's been a long time since I read that book; maybe I should reread it to see if it really does fit (and because I've always enjoyed Clarke's work).
Dwig -- in "Childhood's End" they were "Overlords," and there was an "Overmind." I don't remember "Others."
"Others" have shown up in a lot of fiction; as often as not they are ghosts, demons, or secret human societies, not always space aliens.
Well! This is an unexpected turn!
My bet is that Anna's "Others" story turns out to be hooey. We have the Cetans to show us that even a planet awash in hydrocarbons will not allow a species to leave. If this is from another species it will have to communicate something even more depressing to the believers in the religion of progress. Perhaps that would be that all species end.
You cannot escape your planet and you cannot persist forever?
About the downloaded programs, I'm a bit reminded of Rudy Rucker's Ware series of books. He imagines personalities being transmitted across space as software, running in the computers where they land.
http://www.rudyrucker.com/wares/
(Deborah Bender)
'“Anna,” I asked her, “did your parents tell you any of this?”
She turned to face me then. “A little,” she said. “My mother told me about the Others just before she died. I didn’t know what to make of it. Now I do.” '
The obvious follow up question would be, "What did your mother tell you about the Others?" I expect Trey asked that question, and was answered.
Feeling like one of Dickens' installment readers.
If the Cetans are not a hoax, then I hope the Cetans are ok.
JMG, and the gallant band of musing-minds following this story: I you haven't yet done so, you might be intrigued to study physicist/mathematician Tom Campbell's 'My Big TOE'.
That's the name of his website too.
Tom's Big Theory Of Everything bring's what looks to me like a game-changing perspective to our musings about ourselves and our universe(s).
Give it a look.
The quickest way in, perhaps, is to go to the videos page on his website, and make a bit of time to view some of his presentations, as recorded there. His keynote address to a recent Monroe Institute conference is a useful quick two-hour overview of his history, and his ideas. The sequence called 'Tom Campbell in Spain' and the sequence of his weekend presentation at Calgary University both give a longer development. Both the long ones are about 15-18 hours viewing time -- but richly rewarding of your time investment. To get fully up to speed with his ideas, you might need several viewings, with brewing times in between. It's taken me quite a few months.
Tom may well be the bearer of the next big paradigm-shift in the worldview of modern physics.
Of course the 'Others' will not be the benevolent saviors Anna imagines them to be; readers of JMG's other blog know the contempt he has for the cult of UFO Space Brothers.
No doubt Anna is eager to validate, in her own mind at least, the work her parents did, and to believe that they did not die in vain. But of course they did die in vain.
No, the signal from the Others is clearly malicious-- the only question is, are the Others actually aliens, or does the signal have an earthly source? I am leaning toward the latter: a forgotten but still-broadcasting relic from one of Meriga's many enemies during the Old Time, arranged somehow to seem like it was coming from outer space, a clever ploy to hack the U.S. government's most sensitive computers. The people at Star's Reach finally realized this, and realized that their generations-long study of the Others was all for nothing, so they killed themselves in despair.
-troy
Spanish fly, I've occasionally wondered if the first alien civilization to pick up our television signals deciphered them, and sent out a warning to the rest of space: "Stay out of that solar system -- those creatures are stark staring nuts!!!"
Alphonse, stay tuned...
Hal, ingenious!
Bill, and they can also write about things that other people think exist. Stay tuned...
Dwig, definitely reread it. It's a fine example of the mythologizing of space.
Twilight, stay tuned...
Peter, wasn't Rucker the guy who invented the concept of the Singularity? That sounds like his kind of logic.
Unknown Deborah, I feel rather like Dickens now and again!
Ray, a message from them arrived in episode 24, so they were certainly alive, and worried, just over ten years prior to Trey's arrival at Star's Reach. There'll be more info about them shortly.
Rhisiart, I've had several people recommend Campbell's work to me; since I have a large stack of books to read at any given time, and Campbell apparently takes more than 800 pages to make his point, I've tried to find useful info about his ideas online, in some form more compact than two hours of video or 800+ pages of rambling prose. Everything I've seen suggests that what he's offering is simply standard New Age religious mythology decked out in the terminology of physics; in particular, nobody who's reviewed him has indicated that he makes a single falsifiable hypothesis -- in which case what he's offering isn't science, much less a scientific breakthrough, but one more personal vision. If I'm wrong, by all means point me to the testable, falsifiable hypotheses he's proposed.
Troy, stay tuned... ;-)
Rhisiart Gwylim - from a footnote to a post I put up last October:
*TOE = Theory of Everything. Why a dig, you ask? Well... while Campbell preempts this objection (go ahead, read his book, watch his talks) - I'll just say that when you glibly place consciousness as the over-arching reality in which material existence is just a subset, then you very easily can then slide into an holistic explanation of any phenomenon that may cross your scientific mind. It's reality as virtual reality, and it really is no difference from any religious or metaphysical system.
Not that there's anything wrong with that. Just don't try to shoehorn it into the natural sciences.
http://deconstructingthemanifest.blogspot.com/2012/10/my-modest-big-toe.html
JMG re Campbell (whom I have not read yet either): "nobody who's reviewed him has indicated that he makes a single falsifiable hypothesis -- in which case what he's offering isn't science, much less a scientific breakthrough, but one more personal vision. "
The comical bit is that the same is true of String Theory, yet for some bizarre reason it is considered to be science! Well, OK, they have made one successful prediction -- the existence of gravity. They actually claim it is just a chronological accident that this "prediction" is not counted as valid just because the phenomenon was "discovered" a few millennia before they predicted its existence.
On another note, I had the same thought as Troy, but (I may be wrong here) don't mass suicides tend to happen because of a belief system, not just despair?
Oh ye gods, I may have just put 2 and 2 together.. oh my, oh my... how many installments are left??
Bill, I'm no more impressed with string theory than you are. The thing that seems to be neglected increasingly in, ahem, "cutting edge science," is that if a theory doesn't make any falsifiable predictions that haven't yet been tested, it doesn't matter. Unless it tells us something we don't already know about the universe, it has exactly the same value as going "blerwm, blerwm, blerwm" with your finger on your lips, the way the bards of Maelgwn Gwynedd did after Taliesin put his spell on them.
The story? Around a dozen more installments -- I still have several loose ends to tie up, but it's more or less on track to wind up around episode 60.
Dear JMG,
Just finished devouring After Oil.
Great collection!
I appreciated your introductory exegesis on the evolution and cultural significance of SF, especially the points of having its roots in a subculture of actual, testable science, and its ability to inspire.
In addition to the enjoyable stories and fascinating takes on possible futures, I found the crowd-source technique of the collection and the diversity that came with it to be refreshing. It's a lovely example of how we can all stretch our minds to think beyond the immediate status quo and/or our lodged conclusions based on our current cultural conditioning.
Such mindsets have gotten us here to the point of sliding down Hubbert's peak, and it will take fresh and innovative ways of thinking (also based on hard-won previous experience) that will sustain our species in the future.
Having the opportunity to visualize and play with the potential of the future has been lovely.
Thank you for sharing your view and making such inspiration possible.
May we all open our hearts and minds with compassion and the understanding of interdependence as we sojourn into the undiscovered country together.
I'm just bleakly amused by how often Trey needs to resort to the phrase "I've really got to find the time to write about XXX one of these days." I'm one of the people who hopes that among the up-sides of the collapse of technological civilization, is that we'll all have more time for pursuits such as writing and contemplation. So even when Western man is not chasing after fossil-fuelled machines 24/7, there still aren't enough hours in the day, eh? Or is that some of the author's problems bleeding into the character's narrative?? ;)
My guess is that the message is on the level. That still leaves problems though. A message from an ancient space collective is just about as close as one can get to God or the Universe telling you what the score is. Maybe The Circle will find that The Message supports their religious and political teachings/agenda, Gaia's big sister phoning us direct. Maybe they will call it a hoax or deem it the clearly malicious plans of evil lurking space bats.
Trey can make the call on his own or he can bring it to "the appropriate members of your species and make the decision according to your ways." That's likely to cause a fuss, like the one going on here in the comment section, only between factions and powers with plans and guns. And if the appropriate members give the thumbs up we still have to wait 2x19.92 years for the answers to come back from Delta Pavonis.
The last thing any politician wants to hear is a thundering message from the heavens that disagrees with them. Scuze me Mr. Presden Sir, I know you where hoping for some good news in these troubled times, but The Space Collective just called and it looks like they stand for everything that you don't stand for. I've prepared your get away horse and a small band of men who say that they are totally loyal to you regardless of what the heavens say and also they say they have no political ambitions.
Post a Comment